Development of Public management theory

IELTS Academic Reading Passage

Bureaucracy management: The classic one

A

Several theories bridged the gap between strictly private and public sector management. One good example is Max Weber exploring sociologist, who explored the ideal bureaucracy in The Protestant ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. Bureaucratic Theory was developed by a German. Sociologist and political economist Max Weber (1864-1920). According to him, bureaucracy is the most efficient form of organization. The organization has a well-defined line of authority. It has clear rules and regulations which are strictly followed. according to Max Weber, there are three types of power in an organization: 1. Traditional Power, 2. Charismatic power, and 3. Bureaucratic Power or Legal Power.

The Characteristics or Features of Bureaucracy Organisation

B

Weber admired Bureaucracy for its trustworthiness. The Bureaucracy was constituted by a group of professional, ethical public officials. These servants dedicate themselves to the public in return for the security of job tenure among the many advantages of public employment. There is a high degree of division of Labour and specialization as well as a defined Hierarchy of authority. There are well-defined rules and regulations that follow the principle of Rationality, Objectively, and Consistency. These rules cover all the duties and rights of the employees. These rules must be strictly followed. Impersonal relations among the member of the organization. Interpersonal relations are based on positions and not on personalities

C

Bureaucracy organization is a very rigid type of organization. Too much emphasis on rules and regulations which are rigid and inflexible. It does not give importance to human relations. No importance is also given to informal groups which nowadays play an important role in all business organizations. Yet, too much importance is given to the technical qualifications of the employees for promotion and transfers. The dedication and commitment of the employee are not considered. It is suitable for government organizations. It is also suitable for organizations where change is very slow. There will be unnecessary delays in decision-making due to formalities and rules. It is appropriate for static organizations. There is difficulty in coordination and communication.

D

Herbal Simon, Chester Barnard, and Charles Lindblom are among the first of those recognized as early American public administrators. These men ushered in an era during which the field gained recognition as independent and unique, despite its multidisciplinary nature. Simon contributed theoretical separation to discern management, decisions based on values. since one cannot make completely responsible decisions with public resources based solely on personal values, one must attempt to upon objectively determined facts. Simon developed other relevant theories as well. Similar to Lindblom’s subsequently discussed critique of comprehensive rationality, Simon also taught that a strictly economic man, one who maximizes returns or values by making decisions based upon complete information in unlimited time, is unrealistic. Instead, most public administrators use a sufficient amount of information to make a satisfactory decision: they” satisfice.”

E

In decision-making, Simon believed that agents face uncertainty about the future and costs in acquiring information in the present. These factors limit the extent to which agents can make a fully rational decision, thus they possess only” bounded rationality” and must make deci9sion by “Satisficing,” or choosing that which might not be optional but which will make them happy enough. ” Rational behavior, in economics, means that individuals maximize their utility function. Under the constraints they face (e.g. their budget constraint, limited choices,…..) in pursuit of their self-interest.

F

Chester Barnard was also one of the watershed scholars. Barnard published “The Economy of Incentives”(1938), in an attempt to explain individual participation in an organization. Barnard explained organizations as systems of exchange. Low-level employees must have more incentive to remain with the organization for which they exchange their labor and loyalty. The organization (and higher-level employees) must derive sufficient benefit from its employees to keep them, The net pull of the organization is determined by material rewards, environmental conditions, and other intangibles like recognition. He gives great importance to persuasion much more than to economic incentives. He described four general and four specific incentives including Money and other material inducements; Personal non-material opportunities for distinction; DESIREABLE PHYSICal conditions of work; Ideal benefactions, such as pride of workmanship, etc.

A New Humanist Era: Rethinking Power and Management

G

Humanists embrace a dynamic concept of employee and management techniques. This requires a theoretical shift away from the idea that an employee is a cog in the industrial machine. Rather, employees are unique individuals with goals, needs desires, etc.

H

The humanist era ushered in other possible interpretations of such topics as power and management. One of the most significant was Douglas McGregor’s “Theory X and TheoryY. ” McGregor’s work provided a basis for a management framework, a structure upon whose rungs the classic and new-age management might be hung. first, commonly held by early management theorists, Theory X begins with the assumption that humans possess an inherent aversion to work. Employees must therefore be coerced and controlled if management expects to see results. Further, lazy humans prefer direction bordering micromanagement whenever possible.

I

Theory Y is much more compatible with the humanist tradition. This begins with the assumption that work is as natural for humans as rest or play. Further, employees will direct and control themselves as they complete objectives. Humans learn naturally and seek responsibility. Consequently, managers need only to steer employees in a cooperative manner toward goals that serve the organization. There is room for many to create and share power.

J

The Z- Organization can be thought of as a complimentary third element to McGregor’s dichotomy. Z- organizations are Japanese organizations that are a Japanese organizational model. Similar to Theory Y management, Z organizations place a large degree of responsibility upon the employees. Further, relatively low-level employees are entrusted with the freedom to be creative, ” wander around the organization” and become truly unique, company-specific employees. However, employees achieve only after “agreeing on a central set of objectives and ways of doing business” In Z Organizations, decision-making is democratic and participatory. Despite the many ADVANTAGES OF THIS ORGANIZATIONAL MODEL, THERE ARE SEVERAL DRAW-BACKS. THESE INCLUDE THE DEPREDATION OF A LARGE PROFESSIONAL DIstance-depersonalization is impossible in Z-organizations. Since, in reality, there is a high percentage of workers who would like to work for the financial return than the job objectives. A high level of self-discipline is also necessary.

QUESTIONS 1-2

Choose Two appropriate letters and fill in boxes 1-2

What are the features and advantages of Bureaucratic Management?

  A There are equal opportunities coming from little hierarchy of authority among companies

  B employees‘ promotion can be much fairer which is based on job duties not on characters

  C employees enjoy a greater freedom of duties than their strict right

  D selection and Promotion is based on mastery of new technology

  E these employees can dedicate themselves to the public for stability of a long term job

QUESTIONS 3-4

Choose Two appropriate letters and fill in boxes 3-4

What are the limitations for the ideas of Bureaucratic Management?

  A commitment of the employee is not taken into consideration enough

  B there is difficulty in decision-making based on formalities and rules

  C employees are casually organized as no importance is given to formal groups

  D There is difficulty in enforcement of rules and regulations

  E it is not applicable to dynamic organizations where change is very fast

QUESTIONS 5-6

Choose Two appropriate letters and fill in boxes 5-6

What are the aims of management as Douglas McGregor’s work of the “Theory Y”

  A employees must be coerced and controlled if management expect to see results

  B employees has natural tendency for rest or play

  C humans will not automatically seek responsibility

  D managers may guide employees in a cooperative manner toward objectives

  E there is little room for manager to designate or share his power

QUESTIONS 7-8

Choose Two appropriate letters and fill in boxes 7-8

What are the limitations for the “Theory Z”

  A decision-making is democratic and participatory

  B organization mode has inherent design fault

  C not all employee set higher interest in the job than that of wages

  D personalization remains un-eliminated in organizations

  E self-discipline is an unnecessary quality

QUESTIONS 9-13

Use the information in the passage to match the people (listed A-E) with opinions or deeds below.

Write the appropriate letters A-E in boxes 9-13 on your answer sheet

NB Some people may match more than one ideas

A. Mark Weber

B. McGregor

C. Herbert Simon

D. Chester Barnard

E. Charles Lindblom

  1. Employees like to follow professional, ethical public officials to secure a job

  2. Highly effective can be achieved only after agreeing on a core of objectives and method of doing things

  3. Managers need to take the employees‘ emotional feeling, besides the material rewards, into incentives system.

  4. Individuals can maximize their self-interest when all the budget and choices are utilized well

  5. The assumption that humans possess a natural dislike to work who ought to be forced and controlled

Check Your Answers After Doing Test
Questions Set 1 Answers

Solution for: Development of Public management theory

Answer Table

1. B 8. D
2. E 9. A
3. A 10. B
4. E 11. D
5. B 12. C
6. D 13. B
7. C

Resources:

Do you want to learn more about Otter?

Study Abroad

Academic Reading Passages

Finding our way

Finding our way

A “Drive 200 yards, and then turn right,” says the car’s computer voice. You relax in the driver’s seat, follow the directions and reach your destination without error. It’s certainly nice to have the Global Positioning System (GPS) to direct you to within a few yards...

EXTINCT: THE GIANT DEER

EXTINCT: THE GIANT DEER

PASSAGE Toothed cats, mastodons, giant sloths, woolly rhinos, and many other big, shaggy mammals are widely thought to have died out around the end of the last ice age, some 10,500 years ago. Extinct: the Giant Deer A The Irish elk is also known as the giant deer...

Educating Psyche

Educating Psyche

Educating Psyche Educating Psyche by Bernie Neville is a book which looks at radical new approaches to learning, describing the effects of emotion, imagination and the unconscious on learning. One theory discussed in the book is that proposed by George Lozanov, which...

Economic Evolution

Economic Evolution

A Living along the Orinoco River that borders Brazil and Venezuela are the Yanomami people, hunter-gatherers whose average annual income has been estimated at the equivalent of $90 per person per year. Living along the Hudson River that borders New York State and New...

Eco-Resort Management

Eco-Resort Management

A Ecotourism is often regarded as a form of nature-based tourism and has become an important alternative source of tourists. In addition to providing the traditional resort-leisure product, it has been argued that ecotourism resort management should have a particular...

IELTS Academic Reading – Band Score Description and Calculation

IELTS Academic Reading FAQs

IELTS Academic Reading FAQs What types of texts will I encounter on the IELTS Reading test? You may encounter a range of text types, including academic articles, reports, newspaper articles, and advertisements. The texts will cover a range of topics, from science and...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This